Sanitation vs. vaccination in cholera control

IVI scientist Dr. Anna Lena Lopez with local children during oral cholera vaccine trial in Kolkata, India, Aug 2006. Photo: IVI

IVI scientist Dr. Anna Lena Lopez with local children during oral cholera vaccine trial in Kolkata, India, Aug 2006. Photo: IVI

Only weeks away from the launch in India of an oral cholera vaccine significantly cheaper than available vaccines, community workers and health officials are still sceptical of whether a vaccine is the best way to control cholera, according to the International Vaccine Institute (IVI).

IVI’s director John Clemens told IRIN some water and sanitation programme managers argue that the focus in cholera control should be on safe water access rather than vaccine development.

[…] Introducing a cheaper vaccine in endemic countries “does not mean diminishing the importance of safe water access”, said IVI’s Clemens. “It is a false dichotomy to pit sanitation against vaccination. Improved water and sanitation is the ultimate, but still far-off, goal for impoverished [endemic] countries. Meanwhile we need to think about inexpensive ways to augment efforts [to control cholera].”

Clemens told IRIN that despite a decade of education about the importance of sanitation and safe drinking water, cholera infections have not declined. “Rather, in recent years there have been unprecedented outbreaks of unprecedented duration [in places] where [cholera] had not been [as serious] a problem in recent years.”

[…] People living in countries hardest hit by cholera can ill afford the only internationally licensed vaccine sold as Dukarol, Clemens told IRIN. […] Dukarol can cost up to US$30 per dose and requires at least two doses with boosters. IVI’s new vaccine, Shanchol, is expected to cost about $1 per dose and calls for two doses.

Other more affordable oral vaccines are not licensed internationally.

IVI’s oral vaccine is in the final phase of a clinical trial in India where 70,000 patients have been tracked since 2006. The manufacturer is expecting to produce five million doses in the first year of immunisations. IVI’s director said the vaccine has not been tested on infants under one year old. IVI, based in Seoul, South Korea, started cholera research in 1999 with almost $40 million from The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. The institute received an additional $20 million in 2006 to introduce a cholera vaccine in endemic countries. As the cholera vaccine is licensed only in India, IVI will seek WHO’s approval in late 2009.

See IVI’s page on its cholera vaccine programme.

Source: IRIN, 14 May 2009

One response to “Sanitation vs. vaccination in cholera control

  1. The new vaccine Shanchol may be acceptable and affordable to the masses living in remote rural/slum areas wherein access to safe drinking water and sanitation is often a challenge. Development administration and sector-wide approach for addressing health related issues is yet not a ground reality in developing countries. So, the new vaccine can be an efficacious public health intervention in identified high risk-pocket areas depending on the local epidemiological contexts.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s